NJ's Most Italian Town

It started with a single Sicilian farmer in 1863. Now Hammonton has the highest percentage of Italians in the Garden State.

Posted January 17, 2012 by Nick DiUlio

Members of the Our Lady of Mount Carmel Society escort religious statues in Hammonton’s annual Italian Festival, the longest-running in the country.

Photo by Elena Parker.

Those who donate to the society and church by pinning money to the statues receive a prayer card in return.

Photo by Elena Parker.

Italian specialties fill the refrigerated case at Bagliani’s Market on Bellevue Avenue in Hammonton.

Photo by Elena Parker.

Large signs leading into Hammonton inform visitors they are about to enter “The Blueberry Capital of the World.” What the signs don’t say is that visitors are also entering the unofficial Italian-American capital of Jersey.

According to the 2010 census and the latest American Community Survey figures, 44.6 percent of Hammonton’s 14,791 residents are of Italian ancestry, the highest percentage in New Jersey. (Toms River has the most residents of Italian ancestry, 29,313, but that is just 33 percent of the town’s population.) 

“Italian heritage is a huge part of our identity here,” says Kristin Keating (nee Colasurdo), president of the Hammonton Historical Society. “We’ve kept a lot of traditions alive from generation to generation, and we take great pride in our past.”

The roots of Hammonton’s Italian heritage can be found literally in the ground. Officially incorporated in 1866, Hammonton was the product of an agrarian vision shared by two Philadelphia land-development partners, Charles Landis (founder of nearby Vineland) and Richard Byrnes. “[The soil] was mostly sand, but it had a very high organic content,” says Harry Stafford, trustee of the historical society and Hammonton resident of 40 years. “They called it green sand. With enough water, you could grow almost anything.” By the late 1800s, Hammonton was one of the country’s largest exporters of all kinds of berries.

By almost every account, the unprecedented Italian influx can be attributed to one man, an Italian farmer named Salvador Calabrese who came to Hammonton in 1863 from tiny Gesso, Sicily. Calabrese wrote to two of his countrymen in Gesso, petitioning them to come start farms of their own. Within a few years most of the town of Gesso had relocated to Hammonton. Additionally, an organization called the Italian Labor Bureau was contracted at the time to supply Italian day laborers from nearby Philadelphia to harvest crops and work the fields. Slowly but surely, says Stafford, these laborers began buying land of their own and encouraging family members in Italy to join them.

By 1920, Stafford says, Italian surnames comprised more than 60 percent of the population. This new generation played a major role in Hammonton’s growing textile industry. By 1930, Hammonton was home to about a dozen different garment factories.

Today, for all its ethnicity, Hammonton has just an average number of Italian restaurants, delis and pizzerias. But the standout event on the calendar is the annual Italian Festival sponsored by the Our Lady of Mount Carmel Society. What began in 1875 as a traditional Roman Catholic two-mile long procession of saints has evolved into the longest running Italian festival in the country, with a weeklong carnival and festivities erupting every July.

Agriculturally, winemaking has emerged in recent decades as one of Hammonton’s most vibrant industries. The town is home to three celebrated South Jersey vineyards: Plagido’s Winery, DiMatteo Vineyards and Tomasello Winery, which was started by one of the town’s oldest Italian families and has been making wine for almost 80 years.

“We are the next generation of leaders, and we have a sense of pride in our heritage,” says Keating. “We’re all Americans, but we will also continue to preserve our past.”

For more stories about: Hammonton, parade, Italian, Italian American