Our 3 Favorite Spots for Crumb Cake

There's no doubt about it: The Garden State knows its streusel.

B & W
At B & W, the ratio of crunchy crumb to yeasted cake is a classic 1.5 to 1. Photo by Laura Baer

[Editor’s note, updated April 13: Some bakeries have temporarily closed during the COVID-19 pandemic, as noted below. The ones still open are taking special precautions to protect customers, but could use your support more than ever. As always, we urge readers to take all necessary precautions as advised by health experts.] 

While no one can prove where crumb cake started, all Jerseyans worth their streusel will tell you the best comes from the Garden State. Coffee cakes with streusel topping originated in Germany (streusel in German means “scattered” or “strewn”), so it’s generally accepted that German immigrants brought the original to America. Somewhere along the way, a clever baker realized that buttery streusel was so good, it was worth doubling, even tripling, the amount—and Jersey crumb cake was born.

The pale-yellow cake topped with boulders of dense streusel covered in a blizzard of confectioners’ sugar can be found in bakeries up and down the state. Perhaps you are a classicist who insists on a yeast-risen cake, less sweet and a little chewier than a moist butter cake leavened just with baking powder. Maybe you don’t care, as long as there is an avalanche of crumb topping. Here are our top picks:

READ MORE:
Your Guide to the Garden State’s Best Bakeries
6 Delicious Destinations for Pie
7 Bakeries to Visit If You Have Dietary Restrictions

B & W

Hackensack

(Temporarily closed)

Style: Classic • Ask for a piece of crumb cake at this old-fashioned bakery (cash only!) and the friendly staff gently indicate that a piece is a 7-by-9-inch slab. B & W (Boehringer & Wiener, opened in the early 1940s) makes traditional crumb cake, with a 1.5-to-1 ratio of crunchy, crumbly streusel over not-too-sweet yeasted cake.

614 Main Street, 201-342-5577

Just Crumb Cake

Park Ridge

Style: Variations • Owner Leo Sciancalepore favors crumb lovers with a 2-to-1 ratio of streusel to cake. Just Crumb offers more than 10 flavors of butter cake beyond the vanilla-rich standard, including a chocolate version made with chocolate cake, chocolate ganache and chocolate chip crumbs. The stunner is the rainbow-cookie crumb cake, which looks and tastes exactly like the multi-layered cookie, but topped with crumb and drizzled chocolate.

176 Kinderkamack Road, 201-391-6300

Muellers

Bay Head

Style: Maximum Streusel • When Mueller’s opened in 1890, it immediately began selling crumb cake and has maintained a high standard ever since. With Mueller’s version, the half-inch of cake acts as an edible plate for a feast of rich crumb, piled on in a 2-to-1 ratio.

80 Bridge Avenue, 732-892-0442

Click here to leave a comment
Read more Eat & Drink articles.

By submitting comments you grant permission for all or part of those comments to appear in the print edition of New Jersey Monthly.

Required
Required not shown
Required not shown