We have reached the Championship Round, as four great pizzerias have risen to the top of New Jersey Monthly’s 2018 Pizza Poll, sponsored by Reno’s Appliance. At the front of the pack based on last week’s voting is Reservoir Restaurant in South Orange, followed closely by Pasty’s in Paterson; Tony D’s in Caldwell; and Star Tavern in Orange.
Some 2,919 votes were cast in round three of the poll, which aims to identify New Jersey’s best pizza. We started with 50 pizza restaurants from throughout the state, and reduced the field to 30 after the first week’s voting, and down to 10 after the second week. The restaurants with the top-4 vote totals for the past week now proceed to the Championship Round.
The ultimate 2018 Pizza Poll winner will be announced March 27 on this website.
This week you can vote for one favorite from among the remaining contenders. Voters are eligible to enter for a chance to win a $50 American Express gift card. Three gift cards will be awarded in a random drawing; one card per winner. Fill out the information below the poll for a chance to win.