Easy Eating At Cornerstone Kitchen & Tap

A popular bar and restaurant in Jackson offers local brew and comfort eats.

It’s a rainy winter mid-week night and the parking lot of this L-shaped shopping center in the heart of commuter country in Jackson is as crowded as a mall the Saturday before Christmas. Drivers of SUVs are following folks heading to their cars, ready to pounce for a parking spot.

True, there’s a slew of restaurants here—Surf Taco to standard suburban Italian—but none is hopping more than Cornerstone Kitchen & Tap, where an ever-evolving lineup of craft brews and a menu of modern-day comfort food fuel the families who have pumped up the population of a community that was, a generation ago, considered sparsely populated.

Flights of brews sit on many tables and at the sizable bar that anchors part of the dining room. The Atlantic Highlands-based brewer, Carton, is featured on this night with no less than eight different beers, including the sought-after 077xx DIPA, Nitro Carton of Milk, and This Town Lager. Flights are $10 or $12, depending on your choice of brews; good deal, my beer-geek companions tell me.

I think the meat-and-potatoes starter is a good deal, since the meat’s shredded short rib of beef and the spud portion of the plate potato-stuffed pierogies. It’s mild, quite mild, actually—as are most of the dishes I try at Cornerstone. Nothing here pushes the edges of flavor or gives a dish a shake of pronounced spice to wake up the taste buds. No, Cornerstone is about easy eating.

Meat and potatoes

So the “Sriracha” lime wings taste more of sweetness, with only a hint of lime offering a smack of tanginess and a short stack of carrots and onions, billed as pickled, having just a suggestion of vinegar.

“Sriracha” lime wings

The market salad is fine enough, a toss of greens, slivers of pear, shots of dried cranberries and almonds sitting under a tame apple vinaigrette. Shaved brussels sprouts, promised on the menu, were needed in more than a cameo appearance on the plate.

Market salad

If you like your shrimp-‘n’-grits creamy and plied with Parmesan, you’ll smile at the bowl set before you here, crowned as it is with a generous rasher of shrimp, a dollop of bacon jam and a spray of Cajun oil. Just realize the Cajun oil won’t rock your world with heat; that’s not Cornerstone’s way.

Shrimp and grits

Pulled pork tacos? Heavy on the pico de gallo and onions and light on sauce for the pork. But the skinny fries served in a baggie are awfully fun. And that goes double for the beer-battered fish and chips, which turned out to be my favorite plate here: Moist fish, properly fried with a batter neither thick nor thin, coupled with a remoulade scented with green Tabasco work it well.

Fish and chips

We snag a Belgian waffle with a scoop of pumpkin ice cream with squiggles of caramel-espresso sauce for dessert. Yup, that ice cream needs more pumpkin to be labeled as flavored with anything and the sauce is simply bland. Could the waffles have used a shot of cinnamon? Couldn’t hurt.

The Cornerstone crowd is thinning out as folks finish their brews and genuine whopper-size burgers. Tomorrow is, after all, another school day.

Cornerstone Kitchen & Tap, 21 South Hope Chapel Road, Jackson. Open daily for lunch and dinner. 732-994-5286; cktjackson.com.

Click here to leave a comment
Read more Table Hopping articles.

By submitting comments you grant permission for all or part of those comments to appear in the print edition of New Jersey Monthly.

Required not shown
Required not shown