Cupcake Gets a New Taste Twist

What happens when the powers of Twizzlers, social media and my favorite New Jersey cupcakery combine?

It’s no secret that Twizzlers are my weakness. I have a Costco-size box of 180 sitting at my desk, which my co-workers and I attack around 3 pm every day.

So imagine how ecstatic I was when, one afternoon in early July, I read a conversation on Twitter between Maureen Jaret, co-owner of Stuffed Cupcakes in Nutley, and one of her followers, suggesting that the shop should come up with a Twizzler cupcake.

I didn’t know the context of that comment, but I didn’t care. I pounced. I tweeted Jaret, “I’d like to pre-order a dozen of those Twizzler cupcakes.” The next day, she replied, “I am so going to have to work on this!!! LOL!!” I wasn’t certain if she was serious, but a follow-up tweet later that day saying Keith, her husband and partner, was on the project, gave me hope.

A week later, Jaret tweeted again, asking whether I would like strawberry-flavored or licorice-flavored Twizzlers? After getting a resounding response of “strawberry” from family, friends and co-workers, I tweeted my preference.

On July 23, a Jaret tweet announced the debut of the Twist and Shout, a vanilla-and-strawberry Twizzler cupcake, stuffed with strawberry Twizzler mousse, and topped with vanilla icing and Twizzlers. I was salivating – and on my way for a sample.

It’s hard to replicate flavors, but when I tasted the vanilla-and-strawberry Twizzler cake, it seemed as though I was biting into a soft Twizzler. The best part is the surprise inside, which I won’t spoil for you. But I warn you – this treat is not for the faint-of-sugar.

Read more From the Editors articles.

By submitting comments you grant permission for all or part of those comments to appear in the print edition of New Jersey Monthly.

Required
Required not shown
Required not shown