Trinklein tells the stories of states that tried to be, like Acadia (northern Maine), Lincoln (the top of Idaho), and a third Dakota.
South Jersey, he says, is one of those that came closest to reality.
“In November of 1980, five of six counties in the south voted in favor of secession in a referendum. That’s rather remarkable,” he says. If the referendum had passed, the state would have been divided along a borderline extending from Trenton to just above of Atlantic City.
Even though the South Jersey state movement failed, Trinklein says the region used its clout garner more say in the state. “Proponents actually achieved 95 percent of their goals, not the least of which was defeating gubernatorial candidate James J. Florio—who was seen as an enemy of southern New Jersey. Without the South Jersey statehood movement, Thomas Kean probably would not have been elected.”
In doing his research for the book, Trinklein was surprised by what he learned of New Jersey. He thought the entire state was one big urban area, and we all talked like characters in The Sopranos.
“Admittedly, northern New Jersey is urban and asphalt covered,” he writes in Lost States. “But the south and western parts of the state are surprisingly rural and unspoiled. It’s this dichotomy that has led to 300 years of attempts to divide the state in two.”
Need more on the North/South Jersey border? Steve Chernoski of New Jersey: The Movie looks at how the state divides per NHL team preferences, just in time for the Flyers/Devils match up in the Stanley Cup Playoffs.