Castle Rock Bar & Grill in West Orange

STYLE

Neighborhood joint with a large bar area that includes high-top tables and bar seats. The separate dining area has booth and table seating.

THE SCOOP

This is the first Jersey restaurant for owner George Sanju, a West Orange resident who owns several New York-based eateries.

[RELATED: The 30 Best Restaurants in New Jersey]

THE MENU

Pub favorites make up the menu. Start with the Nachos Phantom, a generous plate of tortillas smothered with chicken or beef, tomatoes, cheese, jalapeños and guac. The cauliflower fritters—batter-fried and bathed in a tangy sauce—are also good for sharing. The restaurant’s signature Wings of Heaven, with a garlicky chili sauce, are another standout pick.

Burgers and wraps, such as the crispy chicken and chipotle wrap with avocado, and sandwiches, including pulled pork, Reubens and Philly cheese steaks, are classic staples. Entrées include hearty Mongolian beef with mushrooms, braised short ribs, and chicken Marsala. Cocktails are creative—try the frothy crème brûlée espresso martini—and well priced.

HEADS UP

Open until 1 am on weekends and 11:30 pm Monday through Thursday. Street parking and a nearby municipal lot are available.

No one knows New Jersey like we do. Sign up for one of our free newsletters here. Want a print magazine mailed to you? Purchase an issue from our online store.