February 2023: Italian Restaurants You'll Love | New Jersey Monthly

February 2023: Italian Restaurants You’ll Love

With more Italian restaurants in New Jersey than any other type of cuisine, it’s nearly impossible to create a definitive list of the best.

But our restaurant critics, led by dining editor Eric Levin, were up to the task, fanning out across the state to visit restaurants, meet chefs and, of course, indulge in great food.

In this issue, you’ll find the 29 restaurants that our critics feel best represent Italian dining in New Jersey. Some are old favorites, others are new to the culinary scene; some only serve the classics, others offer twists. Our critics love them—and we think you will, too. Happy eating!

View more back issues

GARDEN VARIETY

Martin Luther King Jr.’s Civil Rights Career Began at a Modest NJ Café

King’s first-ever recorded sit-in—a little-known confrontation at a Maple Shade tavern in 1950—changed world history.

Keith Dawkins, new president of the Harlem Globetrotters

NJ Native Keith Dawkins Leading Legendary Harlem Globetrotters

Dawkins grew up watching games on TV from his Ridgewood home. Now he’s president of the exhibition team, which makes three stops in NJ this month.

Journalist Susan Glasser on Trump’s Chaotic Presidency—and the Perils of a Second Term

The New Yorker writer and Montclair native authored The Divider: Trump in the White House, 2017-2021 with her husband, Peter Baker.

Kavi American Girl Doll

American Girl’s 2023 Girl of the Year Doll Hails From New Jersey

Kavi Sharma’s story is of an Indian-American girl growing up in a close-knit family in Metuchen.

A volunteer cuddles a baby at in the NICU at Children’s Specialized Hospital in New Brunswick

NJ Baby Cuddlers Have the Sweetest Volunteer Job Around

Patient cuddlers ease the burden for parents and nurses by comforting babies who are hospitalized for an extended period of time.

‘Jersey Italian Love Story’ Is a Funny and Salty New Read

Terri-Lynne DeFino’s romance novel features a colorful cast of Italian Americans—and plenty of Sopranos-esque swagger.

Red leather wallet with gold heart embellishment

Valentine’s Day Gift Guide: Treat Your Sweetheart (or Yourself!)

These glorious goodies and comfy cozies will combat the February doldrums.

Town Clock CDC members

Former Pastor Turned Old Church Into Safe Space for Domestic-Violence Survivors

Town Clock CDC in New Brunswick provides affordable, long-term housing to female survivors of domestic abuse and their children—giving them time to heal.

Young men utilizing services at Brothers Building a Better Nation

Newark-Area Nonprofit Offers Support Services—and Hope—to Local Young Men

Quadeer Porter escaped poverty and went to college. Through Brothers Building a Better Nation, he’s helping others do the same.

FEATURES

A black-and-white photograph of the kosher grocery store in Jersey City that was the site of a shooting in 2019 that targeted Jewish people and law enforcement

Paul Auster’s New Book Probes Gun Violence—and a Shocking Murder in His Family’s Past

In Bloodbath Nation, the Newark native collaborated with his son-in-law, photographer Spencer Ostrander, to examine our country’s gun-violence crisis.

Seton Hall basketball players Dre and Tae Davis.

At Seton Hall, Two Sets of Brothers Make Basketball a Family Affair

With Jamir and JaQuan Harris and Dre and Tae Davis, the Pirates have two pairs of brothers for the first time in program history.

The interior of Angeline at the Borgata in Atlantic City

NJ Italian Restaurants You Must Try

There are more Italian restaurants in New Jersey than any other kind. These are our favorites.

Array of tomatoes

How the Beloved Jersey Tomato Came to Be

A timeline of the fruit we couldn’t live without.

An American kestrel at the Raptor Trust in Millington

Inside the Unique Rehab Center Saving NJ Birds

At the Raptor Trust in Millington, Chris Soucy carries on his late parents’ legacy of running the state’s preeminent wild-bird rehabilitation center.

The interior of Banq on Parq, an 8,000-square-foot event space, formerly the Plainfield Trust Company

NJ Downtowns Are Breathing New Life Into Empty Old Banks

Developers are capitalizing on these historic, character-rich spaces—turning them into restaurants, event spaces, offices and even a vape shop.

The exterior of Farmers & Bankers Brewing in Woodstown

NJ Couple Turned a Vacant Bank Into a Brewery

Deemed one of the state’s most endangered buildings in 2018, the Woodstown structure is now home to Farmers & Bankers Brewing—and a future event space.

HOME & GARDEN

The family room of a Westfield couple's newly renovated home features kid-friendly upholstery

In Westfield, a Luxe But Highly Livable Home

A couple reimagines a family abode for the next generation.

WHERE & WHEN

Newark comedian Bill Bellamy

Bill Bellamy Reflects on Being ‘The Rutgers Comedian’ Before Big Break

The Newark native practiced stand-up on his fellow classmates in the ’80s. This month he’s hosting a star-studded Valentine’s comedy special at NJPAC.

EAT & DRINK

A seafood pasta dish at the GOAT by David Burke in Union Beach

The GOAT by David Burke Boasts Sassy Confidence, Neighborhood Following

On Route 36 in Union Beach, one of Jersey’s hottest celebrity chefs puts an Italian accent on fun, relatable food.

Barbara Morini in her Montclair kitchen, surrounded by ingredients for her pork and beef ragù

She Came to New Jersey for a Better Life—But Brought Her Italian Recipes With Her

“To cook is to be at home, in whatever part of the world I am,” says Montclair entrepreneur Barbara Morini. Her family emigrated here from Italy in 2016.

Fried rice with chicken, beef and seafood at D'Carbon in Paterson

Peruvian Delicacies You Can’t Miss at D’Carbon in Paterson

The restaurant serves traditional Peruvian fare away from the hustle and bustle of Little Lima.

A French omelet with herbs and a side of toast and a cortado at Aunt Chubby's Luncheonette in Hopewell

Try This Classic Luncheonette in Hopewell

Aunt Chubby’s serves all-day breakfast plus soups, salads and burgers.

A cheeseburger at Castaway's Pub in Lavallette

Castaway’s Pub in Lavallette: A Friendly Spot for Bar Staples, Seafood

Enjoy seasonal cocktails, live music and happy hour specials.

Assortment of differently colored negronis

Negronis Are ‘Quintessential’ Italian Aperitif

The negroni is a good way to ease into bitter drinks, says Tania Calabrese, co-owner of Nettie’s House of Spaghetti.

EXIT RAMP

Collage illustration of Black woman with graveyard behind her

Discovering My NJ Hometown’s Ties to Slavery—And Freedom

“My childhood playground was a part of the rich history of Burlington County, a portal to freedom during slavery.”