Friday March 06, 2015SUBSCRIBE
New Jersey Monthly Magazine
| |     

Best of New Jersey: Food and Drink

We asked our readers to list their favorite places to eat and drink, and boy-howdy did they ever respond. Read on to find out which places our readers feel are the best in the state.

Posted March 14, 2011

Do you like this story?

Anthony and Lou Calandra
Brothers Anthony, left, and Lou Calandra with the bread our readers call Jersey’s best.
Photo by Peter Murphy.

Mr. Cupcakes
The offerings of Mr. Cupcakes, a.k.a. Johnny Manganiotis, include this Fruity Pebbles number with cream cheese frosting.
Photo by Laura Moss.

Holsten's in Bloomfield
Our readers say you can count on Bloomfield landmark Holsten’s for Jersey’s best milk shake.
Photo by Laura Moss.

With its firm surface and chewy interior, the Bagels-4-U bagel is a member of a vanishing breed—the traditional, hand-rolled, boiled and baked bagel. Reader Duquina Johnson, a Jersey expat, writes, “I come back from Pennsylvania every month and get a bagel from Bagels-4-U.” (11 NJ locations;
RUNNERS-UP: Sonny’s Bagels, South Orange; Hot Bagels Abroad, Clifton, Verona; Avalon Coffee Company, 7 NJ locations

“We produce it the Old World, European way, all by hand,” says Anthony Calandra of the loaves from Calandra’s Bakery, founded in 1962 by his father, Luciano Calandra Sr. The bakery uses a high-quality short-patent flour, which Calandra says yields superior taste. “Calandra’s hot bread reminds me of my childhood,” writes reader Camille Tonelli of Belleville. “Sundays my dad would always stop at the bakery after church for hot bread, and we would enjoy it with our lunch of pasta and meatballs. The best part was scraping up the last of the gravy with our bread.” (Newark, Fairfield and Caldwell;
RUNNERS-UP: Joe Leone’s, Point Pleasant Beach, Sea Girt; Cait & Abby’s, South Orange, Millburn; Panera Bread

The Losavio family of John’s Meat Market in Scotch Plains is well-known for dry aging its own prime beef. (If you buy elsewhere, “Don’t be fooled; ask to see where it’s stamped US Prime,” says Vincent, son of John, the 1939 founder.) Keeping up with the times, the family, now in its third generation of meat mavens, has added grass-fed beef and a Facebook page. Like the steaks, the service, too, is prime. (389 Park Ave; 908-322-7126;
RUNNERS-UP: Eden Gourmet, South Orange; Sickles Market, Little Silver; Okie’s Butcher Shop, Surf City

As with its bread, the key to the popularity of the Calandra’s Bakery cannoli is that it is handmade from the best ingredients. In addition, the shells (hand rolled around wooden cylinders and baked that way) are filled “20 times a day,” says Anthony Calandra. “We never fill it and let it sit.” (Newark, Fairfield and Caldwell;
RUNNERS-UP: Carlo’s Bake Shop, Hoboken; Rispoli Pastry Shop, Ridgefield; Del Ponte’s Bakery, Bradley Beach; Cipolli Cannoli, Collingswood

Trained in confectionary in Spring Lake and California, Amy Berry-Dunfee opened Red Bank Chocolate Shoppe in 2000. Everything is handmade, from truffles to signature creations like the Riley, a pretzel rod covered in caramel, rolled in marshmallows and Rice Krispies and dipped in milk chocolate. The shop prides itself on custom orders and boxed gift towers. (17 White St; 732-219-0822;
RUNNERS-UP: Enjou Chocolat, Morristown; Mrs. Hanna Krause Candy, Paramus, Toms River

At Watermark, overlooking the ocean in Asbury Park, owner Russell Lewis continues to expand “our culinary approach to the cocktail.” Watermark makes its own grenadine and ginger beer, squeezes all juices fresh and makes all its own vodka infusions, including (it’s about time!) a bacon-infused vodka. New this season is a full kitchen with an in-house chef. “Our food is still tapas style,” Lewis says, “but we have a bit more muscle in that department now.” (800 Ocean Ave; 732-455-3447;
RUNNERS-UP: Langosta Lounge, Asbury Park; Ninety Acres, Peapack-Gladstone; Martini Bistro & Bar, Millburn; Above, South Orange; Daddy O, Brant Beach

If Mara’s Cafe and Bakery in Denville has a mantra, it’s, “from scratch.” Those two words apply to virtually everything the Magley family serves. The popular cheesecakes (“not from a mix,” says son Ian), the gelatos, the cupcakes (the best-selling dessert), the soups. Even the coffee is roasted on the premises. For their 25th anniversary last year, Mara and Glenn Magley and sons Ian and Devan created an Anniversary Blend of Brazilian, Tanzanian, Kenyan and Guatemalan coffees. “It gives you the kick you need,” says Ian, “but it’s as smooth as it gets.” (25 E Main St; 973-625-0901;
RUNNERS-UP: The Fine Grind, Little Falls; Rockn’ Joe, Millburn; America’s Cup, Asbury Park; Grooveground, Collingswood; Starbucks

Getting bounced from the first round of the Food Network’s Cupcake Wars last year “actually worked out great,” says Mr. Cupcakes founder Johnny Manganiotis. “People were coming in just to say I got robbed. They try a cupcake and say those judges don’t know nothing.” Manganiotis recently added a store in Oradell to his store in Hackensack and the original in Clifton. At all three, red velvet and French toast are the best sellers. His aim is to open a store a year, and with three stores in three years, he says he is on track. (
RUNNERS UP: The Stuffed Cupcake Place, Nutley; Mara’s Cafe and Bakery, Denville; Sugarush, Red Bank; Kati’s Kupcakes, Moorestown

“We bake our own roast beef, turkey and ham, and we overstuff the sandwich,” says Anthony Calandra of the heroes at Calandra’s Bakery. “But the bottom line to any sandwich is the bread. We don’t use a sub roll, we use a loaf of our real Italian bread. It costs three times as much, but since we make it ourselves, we don’t have to charge a ridiculous price for it.” (Newark, Fairfield and Caldwell;
RUNNERS-UP: Millburn Deli, Millburn; Joe Leone’s, Point Pleasant Beach, Sea Girt

In its 13-year existence, Harold’s New York Deli in Edison has never changed its menu; it just serves more and more of the same, especially of its best-selling, house-made pastrami and corned beef—8,000 pounds of each a week. Roast beef and turkey sandwiches clock in tied for third. “Whenever the economy is slow, we’re busier because we give such good value,” says owner Harold Jaffe. “People walk out of here with doggie bags.” (3050 Woodbridge Ave; 732-661-9100;
RUNNERS-UP: Eppes Essen, Livingston; Irving’s Delicatessen, Livingston; Kibitz Room, Cherry Hil

Apart from the freshness of all the ingredients, the secret of Ibby’s Falafel rests with Mom. “We use the unique spices created by my mother years ago,” says owner Adnan Kwara, speaking of what goes into the chickpea-based falafel balls themselves. “And that recipe hasn’t leaked out to nobody.” Not a secret is the source of the restaurant’s name. Ibby is the nickname of Kwara’s son Ibrahim, who, like the restaurant, is 16 years old. (Jersey City and Freehold;
RUNNERS-UP: Beyond Pita, Montclair; Maoz Vegetarian, New Brunswick; Norma’s Mediterranean Restaurant, Cherry Hill

“All our french fries are made to order,” says Steve Ranuro of Biggie’s Clam Bar. “They’re never just sitting around.” Seasoned on the spot, Biggie’s waffle fries can be anointed with chili, cheese, cheese and gravy (a.k.a. disco fries) or “whatever someone wants,” Ranuro says. (Hoboken, Carlstadt;
RUNNERS-UP: Curley’s Fries, North Wildwood; The Windmill, 8 NJ locations

The gourmet grocery department of Sickles Market in Little Silver is special to owner Bob Sickles because it dates to when the business was seasonal and open-air, before the family built its 20,000-square-foot store. “It’s still a big part of the business,” he says. “I like to say we specialize in quality, freshness and range of product.” Range of product indeed. “They have such an incredible selection,” writes Oakhurst reader Holly Burtchaell. “I always feel like I am in a culinary playground when I shop there.” (1 Harrison Ave; 732-741-9563;
RUNNERS-UP: Garden of Eden Gourmet, South Orange; Market Basket, Franklin Lakes; Joe Leone’s, Point Pleasant Beach, Sea Girt

Need a break from summer heat? For our readers, there’s no better lick of love than Hoffman’s Ice Cream, a Point Pleasant Beach oasis since 1976. Hoffman’s listens as well as scoops. Two of last year’s most popular specials—Key lime pie and Cookie Monster (with Oreos and cookie-dough balls)—will return this year due to customer request, says manager Kim Karkovice. (Point Pleasant Beach, Spring Lake, Little Silver;
RUNNERS-UP: Applegate Farm, Montclair; Denville Dairy, Denville

People can be very particular about milk shakes. But whatever flavor or topping you like (chocolate syrup? fresh strawberries?), Holsten’s in Bloomfield understands. “There’s no right or wrong,” says Ron Stark, one of the owners. If peanut butter cups are your thing, you will flip for the new vanilla peanut butter with peanut butter cups shake, which Stark says tastes amazing because the cups blend so well in the mixer. (1063 Broad St; 973-338-7091;
RUNNERS-UP: Bobby’s Burger Palace, Eatontown; Pop Shop, Collingswood

Owner Milan Pavlovic attributes the success of Country Pancake House in Ridgewood to its “huge portions, very good quality—and a lot of variety.” Part of the fun is the names given to the various combinations, like Tropical Awareness (pineapple and coconut) or Halloween Feast (pumpkin, spice, granola, raisins). “The customers know when you’re cheating them,” Pavlovic says, reversely explaining why his place is always packed. (140 Ridgewood Ave; 201-444-8395;
RUNNERS-UP: Toast, Montclair; PJ’s Pancake House, Princeton; Uncle Bill’s Pancake House, 8 NJ locations

One way to gauge the quality of pizza in a state blessed with dreamy pies is how far a person is willing to travel to get it. Pete & Elda’s in Neptune City, known for its crackly thin crusts, inspires reader Christine Greer of Hoboken. “I drive an hour for it whenever I have a craving,” she writes. “It’s awesome.” Pete & Elda’s has a tradition—eat an extra-extra-large pie all by yourself, receive a free T-shirt. Drop in to see if you have what it takes. (96 Woodland Ave/Rt 35 S; 732-774-6010;
RUNNERS-UP: Star Tavern, Orange; Mack and Manco, 3 NJ locations; Arturo’s Osteria & Pizzeria, Maplewood; Pizza Fusion

Reasons to pop by Kelly’s Tavern in Neptune City on any given game day: great wings, bar pies, corned beef, pastrami and Reuben sandwiches—and 14 big-screen TVs stationed everywhere you look. Manager Chris Lynch says there is always “some kind of special going on” to tame savage appetites and thirsts. They even have a Reuben pizza for the adventurous. (43 Rt 35 S; 732-775-9517;
RUNNERS-UP: Miami Mike’s Sport Zone, East Hanover; PJ Whelihan’s, 8 NJ locations

Sushi Lounge offers delights for the novice and for the sushi sophisticate. Variety isn’t limited to food, either. The list of specialty martinis alone is reason enough to visit (especially for the primo deals of martini night). (Morristown, Hoboken, Totowa;
RUNNERS-UP: Taka, Asbury Park; Yumi, Sea Bright; Ikko Japanese Hibachi Steakhouse and Sushi Bar, Brick

Lest anyone think that a place with 50 wines by the glass and 250 by the bottle is a one-trick pony, Joshua Rosenberg, owner of Rosie’s Wine Bar in Garwood, is introducing a martini menu with up to 10 selections. Not slacking off on his strength, he is also launching wine-and-chocolate pairings while “staying on top of trends. Malbec is hot, Prosecco is hot, sauvignon blanc is coming up,” he says. (514 North Ave; 908-518-9463;
RUNNERS-UP: 16 Prospect, Westfield; Daryl Wine Bar & Restaurant, New Brunswick; Washington Inn, Cape May; Annata Wine Bar, Hammonton; Wine Loft

If the idea of an actual, physical visit to a wine shop seems, well, very 20th century—then consider a virtual visit to the Wine Library of Springfield. From the state-of-the-art website, you can order anything from the store’s vast selection of fine wines with the click of a mouse—and have it delivered by van if you buy five cases or more. The site also features the unique videos of gonzo wine connoisseur-turned-celebrity Gary Vaynerchuk, helping make Wine Library an indispensable resource for wine lovers locally and, indeed, nationwide. (586 Morris Ave; 888-980-WINE;
RUNNERS-UP: Gary’s Wine & Marketplace, Bernardsville, Madison, Wayne; Bottle King, 14 NJ locations; Moore Brothers Wine Company, Pennsauken

Eating wings while watching sports is a sport in itself, which is why Biggie’s Clam Bar opened a third location in Carlstadt last year near New Meadowlands Stadium. “We sell a ton of wings,” says Carlstadt general manager Steve Ranuro, who adds that customers appreciate the choice of three sauces: buffalo, barbecue and teriyaki. (Hoboken, Carlstadt;
RUNNERS-UP: Chicken or the Egg, Beach Haven; Tommy’s Coal Fired Pizza, Red Bank, Oakhurst

Click here for methodology.

Related Articles:

Village Green
Only Mom Need Know: Snacks That Emphasize Nutrition
Pesce Out of Water: Rustic Italian Food in Spring Lake
Cafe Picasso
Millie's Old World Meatball & Pizza

If you like this article please share it.

Pizza n bagels

Pete n Elda’s??????R u kidding me? That pizza is ragu on cardboard. We waited 2 hours to eat there and still question why. Isn’t even worth eating for the tee shirt. Luigi’s in Lincroft. Now that is pizza. And for bagels that r not giant circles of’s got to be the Bagel
Oven in Red Bank.Sickles is totally worthy and Joe Leone’s should have been first for Italian specialties. Who were the tasters here?

Posted by: Linda, Middletown | Mar 23, 2011 02:46:54 AM |

Wine Shop

Your readers missed the mark on best wine shop. I have been collecting wine for nearly 3 decades. No one on your list compares to The Bottle Shop in Spring Lake. I find the selection to be unbelievable and the staff to be straightforward. You will not find any ridiculous gimmicks at The Bottle Shop.

Posted by: James, Holmdel | Mar 23, 2011 03:44:53 AM |


I questions the reliability of this list.
You would think that most of the better establishments are located by the Jersey Shore, whereas the majority of restaurants in general are in locations like Morristown, Montclair, Hoboken and now even Jersey City. Perhaps residents of these towns don’t read NJ Monthly enough to bother writing in.

Posted by: Rick, Union | Mar 24, 2011 00:40:18 AM |

best Italian Bread

I have to say Calandra’s isn’t that bad. If you want to taste the best Italian bread in the state try Demarcos Bakery in Aberdeen. its so crusty and tasty. I use to get their Italian but now I’m stuck on their Rustic bread. I agree with Linda from Middletown, Pete & Elds has a great game bar crowd but not pizza. Sorry.

Posted by: Doreen Gill, Holmdel | Mar 24, 2011 16:21:41 PM |

Restaurant Rankings

THe restaurant rankings are bogus---no basis for the results. How can so many restaurants be on the Jersey Shore---poor food at best! NJ Monthly does this all the time--ie: "Best Restaurants", "Best Lawyers", "Best Brokers", "Best Doctors"---what a crock---it is mostly paid advertising.

Posted by: bob, morristown | Apr 01, 2011 19:19:08 PM |


The best pizza by far is Federici’s in Freehold, not to mention the best Italian food. Not sure why they don’t make the list. Absolutely runs circles around Pete & Elda’s.

Posted by: Heidi Daniels, Aberdeen | Apr 22, 2011 16:40:11 PM |

Mr. Cupcakes

Mr. Cupcakes cupcakes are incredibly delicious! They are definitely the best cupcakes I have ever tasted! Though Carlo’s Bakery’s (Hoboken) red velvet cupcakes are undefeatable, I tried a Chocolate Sundae cupcake and a bite of the Peanut Butter & Jelly, Fruity Pebbles, Mint Chocolate Volcano, and Lemon Drop cupcakes. All were esquisite! My advice: Visit Mr. Cupcakes shops in Clifton, Hackensack, Oradell, or Red Bank. Beside their amazing flavors, they are only $1.50 each! A great buy!

Posted by: Katelyn, Westfield | Jun 05, 2011 22:48:57 PM |

Best Pizza

I have never been to Pete and Elda’s pizza before, but the best pizza I ever had was at Louie’s Pizza in North Cape May. Try it!

Posted by: Arielle, Clark | Jun 05, 2011 22:57:15 PM |

Best Pizza

I have not been to Pete and Elda’s before, and I am sure it tastes great, but the best pizza I ever ate was from Louie’s Pizza in North Cape May. Try it!

Posted by: Arielle, Clark | Jun 05, 2011 22:59:27 PM |

bagels and breakfast

The best bagels come from Razzle Dazzle Cafe in Somerville
located on 53 west main street, everything is fresh and made on the premises. From coffee to pancakes to egg sandwiches made on the best and freshest bagels around. We make all our own cream cheeses too.. Come see for yourself that we have the best bagels around! Open 7 days a week Monday thru Sat 5:30 to 3 pm and Sunday from 7 to 3. You won’t be disappointed!

Posted by: Theresa, Raritan, NJ | Jun 16, 2011 03:49:02 AM |

Best Pizza Jersey Shore

Best Pizza anywhere is at Zachary’s in Oceanport. Thin crust, delicious, and half-price Mondays!
Second Place should be Mauritzios in Neptune. Their sauce is so good, they sell it in jars for you to take home!
Pete & Elda’s???? I’ve been there, once. Terrible; won’t go back.

Posted by: Mick Medlicott, Tinton Falls | Jul 21, 2011 18:34:48 PM |


Recently had Demarco’s in Aberdeen baked sour dough bread and it was to die for! Crispy outside and flavorful and moist inside. Calandra is just OK in my opinion. Dont understand why Applegate farms always gets best ice cream. There are tons of better places including Eddies Confetti in Asbury Park. Also, Delorenzos and Sciortinos Pizza was not mentioned. Forget the cracker crust of Pete and Eldas!!!

Posted by: Joan Ark, Millstone Township | Jul 22, 2011 02:20:25 AM |


I cannot imagine ANY pizza better than Star Pizza in Orange.

Posted by: Laura Randazzo, Monroe Township | Sep 08, 2011 19:27:45 PM |

Thanks for giving me a good laugh!!

This list is a joke, right?!

Posted by: Tony, Lodi | Nov 26, 2011 15:59:28 PM |

Best Pizza

Best Pizza in NJ is Luigi’s in Lakehurst and has been for the past 30+ years...there isn’t a pizza that comes close to the crust and overall taste of those pies! People come from all over just to eat Luigi’s pizza, you must try it!

Posted by: Lisa Dawson, Toms River | Dec 08, 2011 19:39:56 PM |

Best of Jersey 2012

The Best:
Bread - Calandra’s Bakery
Cannoli - Calandra’s Bakery
Cocktails - Calandra’s Italian Village
Cupcakes - Calandra’s Bakery
Deli Sandwich/ Italian - Calandra’s Market and Deli
Pizza - Calandra’s Bakery

Posted by: Louella De Vita, Essex Fells, New Jersey 07021 | Jan 06, 2012 21:26:18 PM |


I agree about the Pete N Elda’s, its the place I would go after a lond day waitressing because it was the only place open late. I do love the passion for everyone’s favorite pizza place though. Porta National Park in Asbury is pretty good, and for a classic oldschool mom and pop pizza place, I highly enjoy a cheap bottle of Ruffino Chianti and a pie at Vic’s in Bradley Beach.

Posted by: Katie Califano, Brielle | Feb 19, 2012 14:10:59 PM |

Best Pizza

If you love thin crust pizza, you have try the pizza at The Columbia Inn in Montville. It’s ultra thin and crisp and very tasty. It can come with a variety of topings as well as different types such as bbq chicken, pesto, veggie, eggplant parm, chicken parm and margherita.

Posted by: Gary Nagurka, Montville | Feb 27, 2012 16:21:08 PM |

best bread

I live blocks from Calandras but drive 40 mins to Brothers Bakery in Kearny. Amazing bread , moved away and lost 20 pounds the first year

Why no decent bakeries in west Essex county?

Posted by: hugh jasse, caldwel | Mar 15, 2012 20:47:13 PM |

Web Analytics