5 Great Record Stores in New Jersey

Whether you're searching for an elusive underground record or just want to peruse the classics, these top-tier record stores have you covered.

Sweet Vinyl Café in Denville
Sweet Vinyl Café in Denville Photo: Courtesy of Sweet Vinyl Café

Vinyl is back with music lovers of all ages! “It’s not a retro thing at all,” says music journalist Adam Budofsky, founder of Sweet Vinyl Café, a record shop and café in Denville. “[Records are] here to stay.”

Across New Jersey, dozens of shops offer stacks of LPs, where customers can spend hours leafing through dusty treasures and new gems alike. Here are a few of our favorites.

Sweet Vinyl Café in Denville

This shop is half-café, half-shop. Enjoy a coffee and some sweets while you peruse records old and new. It’s a space where music lovers can relax and connect.
23 Diamond Spring Road; 973-453-6443

Princeton Record Exchange in Princeton

Buying and selling music since the ’80s, Princeton Record Exchange boasts an abundance of genres that’ll keep browsers busy for hours. In addition to vinyl, including a $1 section, there are CDs, DVDs and more.
20 South Tulane Street; 609-921-0881

Station 1 Books & Vinyl in Pompton Lakes

This store is situated in a former historic train station—a giant caboose sits right next door! There’s a wide variety of vinyl records, plus books, CDs, VHSes and video-game cartridges.
1 Station Plaza; 973-307-0212

Inner Groove Records in Collingswood

Used vinyl is Inner Groove’s specialty. Looking to sell? The staff will sort and grade your LPs. The shop also makes one-of-a-kind reissues of rare classic records.
798 Haddon Avenue; 856-559-6034

Soldato Books & Records in Rutherford

Now operating out of Rutherford’s iconic Williams Center, and inspired by international bookstores, Soldato is a must-visit for anyone on the hunt for underground artists.
15 Sylvan Street; 551-243-1859

[RELATED50 Fun Things to Do on a Rainy Day in New Jersey]


No one knows New Jersey like we do. Sign up for one of our free newsletters here. Want a print magazine mailed to you? Purchase an issue from our online store.