Restaurant Review

The Real Hearth at Hearthside in Collingswood

Chef Dominic Piperno made sure to install a large wood-burning grill and oven when he opened Hearthside in Collingswood in September. He is making good use of the grill—and also turning out some deft pastas.

Photo courtesy of Hearthside

Dominic Piperno used to take the train from his home in Collingswood to and from his job as sous chef at the acclaimed Philadelphia restaurant Vernick Food and Drink. “On the train were all these cooks and servers from Jersey,” he says, “because Philly’s where you can make money to further your career.”

To change the paradigm, Piperno and his wife, Lindsay, a front-of-house veteran, opened Hearthside in Collingswood in September. They built the restaurant to accommodate a big, wood-burning grill and oven like the ones Piperno used at Vernick and during culinary school in Chianti, Italy.

Much of the menu is cooked over wood, from sweet, heads-on Gulf prawns, finished with lemon-garlic butter, to the ethereal apple fritters, their batter enriched with applesauce made from fruit slow roasted in the oven overnight.

The open kitchen and hearth, as they call it, give the restaurant a glow. Aiding the cozy vibe are sensationally comfortable banquettes and cushioned chairs.

Piperno and co-executive chef Aaron Gottesman, friends since they worked together briefly at Vernick, aim to keep things “approachable but not dumbed down,” says Gottesman.

Collingswood’s standout establishment is still the Sicilian BYO, Zeppoli, where Piperno cooked for three years. Hearthside isn’t at that level just yet. During my first dinner, 10 minutes passed before a server appeared at my table, and the food was inconsistent.

On the terrific side: raw tuna with jalapeño-spiked Asian-pear purée, Asian-pear granita, freshly grated horseradish, toasted sesame seeds and olive oil; agnolotti filled with creamy smoked celery root in brown butter; pork chop with chard, smashed potatoes and tangy plum mustard; kale salad massaged with a warm poppy-balsamic dressing on a plate with roasted carrots, crushed hazelnuts and ricotta salata; mascarpone-frosted carrot cake as light as angel food.

On the problematic side: Skate wing, limp and basic, on under-seasoned collards and ham broth; tiny mussels in a too-sweet coconut curry; an inedibly sweet pistachio-rose semifreddo.

A few weeks later, things had improved significantly. Service was personable and proficient. Every dish delivered, including the aforementioned prawns and apple fritters.

Also memorable: beef carpaccio in a savory mushroom vinaigrette with fennel seed and rosemary breadcrumbs; confited octopus marinated in chipotle purée and charred on the grill, served with avocado purée, charred-onion crème fraîche and pickled pearl onions; spice-cured braised lamb shank on creamy rice grits (a milling byproduct from South Carolina’s acclaimed Anson Mills) with big wedges of sweet, licorice-like, caramelized fennel.

But the dish of the night was rabbit tagliatelle, the succulent meat cured, roasted, braised and nestled amidst al dente house-made noodles in a light tomato sauce fortified with reduced braising liquid and fresh oregano.

While at Zeppoli, Piperno made countless plates of chef Joe Baldino’s definitive rabbit cacciatore. The tagliatelle was a clear tribute that also managed to feel original. Piperno and Gottesman added tiny cubes of provolone to the pasta just before serving. It melted slowly into the dish, releasing its pleasantly funky perfume and flavor in counterpoint to the woodsy oregano.

Hearthside has made big strides. If Piperno and Gottesman maintain the momentum, they might even entice Philly chefs to cross the river to work for them.

Restaurant Details

  • Cuisine Type:
    American - Modern
  • Price Range:
  • Price Details:
    Appetizers, $9-$18; entrées, $15-$32; desserts, $3-$9.
  • Ambience:
    Cozy, like a 1950s den, with well-spaced tables and unusually comfortable upholstered chairs.
  • Service:
    Has ranged from blasé to delightful.
  • Wine list:
Required not shown
Required not shown