Princeton can fill a visitor’s day many times over. Whether you check out Princeton University’s superb public art museum, local historic sites (Einstein’s home, Revolutionary War Battlefield Park), a top-ranked theater company, or nearby lakes, churches and parks, you’ll easily work up an appetite.
Fortunately, Princeton’s restaurant scene is varied and vibrant—one of our favorite in the entire state.
Below are our top picks for the best restaurants in Princeton, in alphabetical order.
Why should you trust this list? Put simply, New Jersey Monthly knows New Jersey’s dining scene. Our editors and restaurant critics spend endless amounts of time traversing the state to dine at all types of establishments, from fine-dining restaurants to pizza places, old favorites to new restaurants bringing their own flavor to New Jersey’s culinary scene.
Enjoy!
[RELATED: The Best Restaurants in New Jersey]
Agricola
Savor salmon with greens at Agricola. Photo: Courtesy of Agricola
One of the most distinctive and appealing restaurant and bar spaces in town, Agricola has modern American food to match. International flavors and techniques broaden the appeal. Servers are upbeat, informed and responsive. Good cocktail menu as well.
11 Witherspoon Street, 609-921-2798
The Alchemist & Barrister
Sit down with an egg-topped burger and some fries. Photo: Courtesy of the Alchemist & Barrister
Located in an historic building on Witherspoon Street, the Alchemist & Barrister is a popular watering hole among students and visitors, with a tribute portrait of Einstein painted on the wall. Here you’ll find a variety of good pub food, from flatbreads and tacos to wings and burgers, and a rotating draft beer list.
28 Witherspoon Street, 609-924-5555
Blue Point Grill
Oysters chill on ice. Photo: Courtesy of Blue Point Grill
Since opening in 1999, Blue Point has earned a loyal following for its raw bar (rare back then!) and very fresh fish. Those are still the main attractions, but the menu now includes soups, salads, sides, and a few meat and chicken dishes as well.
258 Nassau Street, 609-921-1211
Conte’s Pizza
Conte’s Pizzeria is a great spot to unwind with some pizza and a pint. Photo: Courtesy of Elena Bruno
Photos of local soccer teams and posters of Italy’s 2006 World Cup champion team set the tone inside this beloved pizzeria, along with a long, glass-brick bar. People wait in line to get a bite of the crisp thin-crust pies with silky housemade sauce. Among many toppings, the pepperoni is particularly good. The small, thick discs curl in the oven, collecting tiny pools of flavorful oil.
339 Witherspoon Street, 609-921-8041
Elements
Sea urchin roe tops French bread-and-cheese patranque. Photo: Stuart Goldenberg
State-of-the-art cooking is always at the forefront here, and that means reaching back in time as well as staying current. Chefs Scott Anderson and Mike Ryan are foragers and students of Japanese, as well as other culinary arts. The wine and cocktail programs are on par with the top-flight food—earning Elements a spot on our Best Restaurants list for a number of years.
66 Witherspoon Street, 609-924-0078
Hoagie Haven
Grab a tasty sub from Hoagie Haven. Photo: Courtesy of Hoagie Haven
First opened in 1974, the Haven, as it’s called, remains popular for its roughly 14 cold submarine sandwiches and equal number of hot ones. There are also hot dogs, burgers, sides, salads and soft drinks. Cash only.
242 Nassau Street, 609-921-7723
Jammin’ Crêpes
Photo: Courtesy of Jammin’ Crêpes
In addition to being a leader in recycling and composting among Princeton eateries, Jammin’ Crêpes makes a point of buying from local farms and making its own jams and fillings from scratch for its sweet and savory crêpes as well as its sandwiches.
20 Nassau Street, 609-924-5387
Mistral
Enjoy a pasta and veggie dish at Mistral. Photo: Courtesy of Mistral
Do you think of Mistral as the lovable little brother of highbrow Elements? They do share ownership and a building, but Mistral has its own character! It hits every sweet spot: moderate prices; flexibility (have a quick, light meal or settle in for a longer one); and one of the most creative yet relatable and delicious menus anywhere.
66 Witherspoon Street, 609-688-8808
Nomad Pizza
Nomad Pizza has two restaurants in Jersey: this one in the Princeton Shopping Center, and another in Hopewell. Nomad’s Neapolitan pies have classic semi-soft interiors and puffy crusts. Beyond the soulful margherita, highlights include the hot soppressata—with tomato sauce, Italian soppressata, mozzarella, red pepper flakes, oregano and a drizzle of honey to temper the assertive spice.
301 North Harrison Street, 609-285-5187
Triumph Restaurant & Brewery
Unwind with a few beers and a cheese platter. Photo: Courtesy of Triumph Brewing
Triumph opened in Princeton in 1995, making it one of the state’s first brewpubs. It now has locations in Red Bank and New Hope, Pennsylvania, but the original still has an upscale and urbane look—plus better-than-average pub food and a rotating selection of craft beers.
20 Palmer Square East; 609-924-7855
Witherspoon Grill
Dig into a delectable pork chop. Photo: Courtesy of Witherspoon Grill
The hot pink center, so to speak, of Witherspoon’s menu is its list of high-quality steaks and chops. Very fresh seafood, including a one- or two-tier cold seafood tower, is another attraction.
57 Witherspoon Street, 609-924-6011
MORE DINING GUIDES:
The Best Restaurants in Montclair
The Best Restaurants in Morristown
The Best Restaurants in Jersey City
No one knows New Jersey like we do. Sign up for one of our free newsletters here. Want a print magazine mailed to you? Purchase an issue from our online store.
By submitting comments you grant permission for all or part of those comments to appear in the print edition of New Jersey Monthly.